Best Remote Dog Training Collars 2019 – Do Vibrating Dog Collars Work?

Training your dog to obey and behave can be a challenging task, one way to make it a little easier for both you and your four-legged friend is to use a training collar. Below we have listed the best remote dog training collars so that you can choose which one suits your needs the best.

If you want to see our top recommended training collar for dogs and skip all the fuzz, the number one spot in this list goes to the Garmin Delta XC Series.

Keep in mind that some collars are better for a specific behavior, such as the vibration collar being better for barking dogs, and the spray collar being a better option for dogs that don’t listen.

Do Vibrating Dog Collars Work?

Over the years we have had the opportunity to test a lot of different training collars, and we must say that the vibrating dog collar is our absolute favorite. While some people still see them as cruel, we feel the vibrating collar is a better option than the shock collar.

Vibrating collars, however, does not work as well for all the different types of breeds when it comes to training purposes. Some breeds have a very strong build and a though neck that do not properly receive the vibrations, while on the other hand, smaller breeds feel them very easily.

In some cases a vibrating collar can be extremely handy, for example, if your dog is turning deaf, then a vibrating collar can be used to call him when without a leash.

A lot of vibrating collars come with different intensity levels, so it should not be a problem to turn up the level if your dog does not react on the lower levels.

The Best Remote Dog Training Collars

We have conducted a list below of our top recommended best remote dog training collars. As you may find, we have not included any shock collars and the reason for that is because it is considered by many to be cruel and inhumane.

Keep in mind that not all the collars in this list are suitable for every dog. If you have a small dog, you don’t want to get a heavy collar and vice versa.


Garmin Delta XC Bundle – Best Long Range Collar

The Delta XC Bundle from Garmin is a 3-in-1 type of training collar. It comes with three different modes for you to choose from.

Start with trying out the different modes, to see which one you like the most, and which one works on your dog. Don’t just start with the shock mode, go for a gentler mode and intensity.

Being a premium quality dog collar, the price is a bit on the high-end, which further proves this product is of high-quality.

Quality and other Specifications

What we like most about this training collar is the long range, from which you can control the collar from your remote control. This collar has a range of up to 1/2 mile, which makes this collar perfect both for outdoor, but also indoor training.

The three different modes available on the Garmin Delta XC are as follows:

  • Tone
  • Vibration
  • Shock

There are also 18 different stimulation levels so that you can start off your training with low intensity and knock it up if required.

Important: We do not endorse animal cruelty, do not abuse your power or punish your dog without cause. We would recommend you to stick with the tone and vibration settings, however, it is always nice to have that extra shock feature should you need it.

With a water-resistant rating of IPX7, this collar is sure to stay functional even if your dog decides to go for a swim in the pool.

To find out more about the Garmin Delta XC series, check out this video review below.

As mentioned in the video, there are three different models of the Delta XC. If you want one of the more advanced models you can have a look at the Garmin Delta XC Sport, or the Garmin Delta XC Upland, both available on Amazon.

+ What We Liked

  • Sturdy, waterproof design
  • Premium quality
  • Long range for outdoor training
  • 3 Different Training Modes, with 18 levels

– What We Didn’t Like

  • The shock feature is very strong
  • High price tag

Check Current Price on Amazon


SportDOG SportHunter SD-825

SportDOG has made some of the most popular training collars on the market, the SD-425 being the predecessor to this newer collar.

Yet another long-range training collar, this one, as well as the before mentioned Garmin Delta XC, has a range of 1/2 mile which makes them ideal for hunting and bird dogs.

Switch up your training with three different modes, and tailor the training to your dog’s needs and the different behaviors you want to discourage.

Quality and other Specifications

Train up to three dogs simultaneously with the same remote control by purchasing additional separate collars. Fits most dogs, from 8 pounds and up.

Also in this collar, you get three different training modes:

  • Static
  • Tone
  • Vibration

Comes with rechargeable lithium-ion batteries that take about two hours for a full charge, and the batteries last for 50-70 hours depending on your chosen mode and settings.

This collar is waterproof and submersible up to 25 feet using the DryTek technology.

If you want to learn more about the SD-825 you can watch the video review posted below.

This collar comes in two different models, the original SD-825 and the new, updated X-series. You can also choose between more advanced controllers with an increased range of up to 1 mile, and being able to simultaneously train 6 dogs at a time.

+ What We Liked

  • Sturdy and high quality
  • Waterproof but not IPX7 graded
  • Good range with improved model up to 1 mile

– What We Didn’t Like

  • Not compatible with older collar models
  • Only 7 different levels of intensity

Check Current Price on Amazon


WolfWill No Shock Training Collar

Shock collars are seen as cruel and inhumane, that’s why we generally try to recommend other alternatives. This collar is also a 3-in-1 training collar but without the shock feature.

The no-shock training collar from WolfWill features three different modes that allow you to further customize your dog’s training needs. It also comes with 16 different levels of intensity.

You can buy two collars and simultaneously train two of your dogs with the same remote control.

Quality and other Specifications

With three different modes, you can tailor your training and switch between the modes depending on the situation, as some modes are better suited for specific behavior. The three modes are:

  • Tone
  • Vibration
  • Light

The range of this collar is up to 660 yards, which makes it perfect for outdoor use but not quite as good as the number one listed above.

This training collar for dogs is also waterproof with an IPX7 rating, which means it will not stop working if your dog decides to go for a swim.

+ What We Liked

  • Premium quality
  • IPX7 waterproof design
  • Good range of up to 660 yards
  • 3 Different Training Modes, with 16 levels of intensity

– What We Didn’t Like

  • The tone was a bit low
  • Might not fit smaller breeds

Check Current Price on Amazon


What is a Training Collar Used For?

Different types of animals show unwanted behavior. Cats spread their litter in the apartment, small dogs bark too much, big dogs jump on strangers. Such kind of behavior can be stopped with a training collar, as well as following:

  • Does not come when called
  • Biting other dogs/humans
  • Constant barking for no reason
  • Strong hunting drive
  • Eating things they are not supposed to eat
  • Peeing in the home
  • Destroying furniture and other things in the home

How Much Does a Training Collar Cost?

The prices vary depending on the type of collar, the cheapest collar is the spiked collar. This can be found online from just a few dollars. For a shock collar, you should expect to pay on average between $30 and $40. The shock collar is supplied with remote control and is rechargeable.

The spray collars are the most expensive, priced around $80-$100.

What Kind of Animals is a Training Collar Suitable For?

Depending on which animal you have a problem with, you should choose the right collar. This can be a big dog pulling on a leash and needing a spiked collar. But even a small dog can benefit from the training with a shock collar if he barks too much.

Some people even want to use a training collar for their cat. It can be used here when your pet distributes its cat litter by scratching indiscriminately throughout the home.

When Should I Use a Training Collar for my Dog?

The collar is generally used against unwanted behavior. It can be used to stop whining and barking, scratching or even biting, jumping up, pawing or use in disobedience. You can also use a training collar if your dog feels a strong hunting drive.

As the presentation of the individual training collars has shown, every function on a collar has a special purpose. For example, if your dog is constantly on a leash, a spiked collar can be a good educational measure. The dog sticks himself in the neck and learns to refrain from doing so.


What kind of education collars are there and which one is right for you?

Basically, one can distinguish between five different types of training collars:

  • Shock Collars
  • Spray Collars
  • Water Collars
  • Spiked Collars
  • Vibration Collars

In each of these collars, the mechanism that admonishes the animal is slightly different. This brings with it individual advantages and disadvantages.

Depending on what you expect from a training collar, one or another type of collar is suitable for you. Therefore, in the following section, let’s take a closer look at the different types of training collars and thereby help you to decide the right one for you.

Generally, a training collar or anti-bark collar works on your dog’s conditioning. While a dog is positively conditioned with treats and rewards, if all else fails, and the dog no longer obeys, use the training collar.

This helps in the negative conditioning, which means that if the dog has done something wrong, he will be punished and will in the future try to avoid these behaviors.

  • In aggression against other dogs
  • With high hunting drive
  • With increased barking
  • Jumping on humans
  • Running away and disobedience

How Does a Shock Collar Work?

Beware that shock collars are not allowed in some countries, it is important that you read up on your countries rules and regulations when it comes to pet products. Nevertheless, let’s explain the advantages of a shock collar, and why you might want to try one out.

Important: While shock collars are considered a cruel training collar that can cause more harm than good to your dog, it is important to note that it is still a good option if used correctly. Never abuse your power and only use the shock collar when unwanted behavior is shown.

The shock collar is thicker than most other types of collars. It comes with a remote control that allows the owner to activate small electric shocks. As soon as the button on the remote control is pressed, the power in the collar is activated. This can teach the animal if it has done something wrong or punish the behavior, for example when the dog barks.

Training collars for dogs
Spray training collars are one of the more enjoyable options for training collars. The animal is terrified, but no physical pain is added. (Photo: PixelwunderByRebecca (pixabay.com)

The shock collar is also commonly used as a so-called ‘invisible fence’. You specify a certain area in which the animal is allowed to move. If the dog leaves this area or moves beyond it, the electric shock is activated. This power collar works without remote control, for example within property boundaries.

This form of training is generally frowned upon and is not something that we promote. We simply mention it for information purposes to cover as wide of a basis as possible to where the shock collar may be used.

How Does a Spray Collar Work?

You can easily train your dog with a spray collar, it is no bigger than a normal collar. A small capsule with spray is attached to it. With the supplied remote control, the training collar can be activated in case of unwanted behavior.

As soon as the spray collar is activated, it releases a small cloud of spray that is designed to scare the dog. Even before the sound of the spray, the dog can be afraid, there are also various types of sprays, for example, with lemon fragrance, which can have a deterrent effect.

The spray is generally odor-neutral or has a pleasant fragrance for humans.

How Does a Spiked Collar Work?

The spiked collar is made out of metal or chromed steel, it is especially effective for dogs that pull on the leash. This training collar lies close to the neck of the dog. If he dodges you too much or pulls you in the wrong direction, the spikes will stick him in the neck, which will make him try to avoid this behavior.

Important: We understand that this type of collar is also a controversial one, even though it is slightly less cruel than the shock collar. It is important that you understand that this collar will cause pain in your dog, which we generally want to avoid.

The spiked collar is banned in some parts of the world, and you should read up on the rules and regulations of your country when it comes to what type of dog collars are allowed and not.

The spiked collar can also be used if your dog is often attacked by other animals. Put the dog in a different direction so that the spikes are pointing outwards. It protects against attackers and keeps them away from the neck of your dog.

How Does a Vibration Collar Work?

Vibration collars are exactly what it sounds like, and a less cruel option than the shock collar. The vibrating module attaches to a regular collar and comes with a pair of prongs that makes contact with your dog’s neck.

When unwanted behavior is detected, most commonly when the dog is barking, the collar lets out a vibration, rather than an electric shock. Some vibration collars also support other types of features, such as sounds that resembles a dog whistle that only the dog can hear.

The training collar comes with remote control, however, not all vibration collars require a remote control as it automatically detects barking. The vibrations that the animal feels are not as painful as, for example, shocks or spikes.


Compare and Rate Training Collars

This section is designed to help you choose the right training collar. Depending on which criteria are important to you, you can compare the training collars with each other and evaluate what is important to you when buying a remote trainer. Specifically, the criteria are:

  • Weight of the Training Collar
  • Special Features
  • Reach
  • Neck Size
  • Weight of the Dog
  • Behavior
  • Batteries
  • Stages

These sections are intended to give you an overview of what a training collar can do and which features there are.

Best training collar for dogs
Dog Training with a Training Collar – This kind of education is often the last call for help of a dog owner who has big problems with his dog. (Photo: KlausHausmann / pixabay.com)

Weight of the Training Collar

Depending on whether you have a larger or smaller dog, the weight of your training collar will play a role. A chihuahua with a weight of four to five pounds would not necessarily like to have a collar designed for a larger breed.

If you are worried that the weight of the dog collar you have chosen may be too much for your dog, you can also check under the dog’s weight section which dog weight your dog should have in order for this dog collar to be recommended.

Special Features

For the different types of training collars, manufacturers always come up with something new to make the collar extra special. For example, with some spray collars, you can choose between different odors.

Cesar Millan’s education collar lets you choose a specific color. On some education collars, LEDs are also attached, so you can easily see your dog in the dark.

Also, the included remote control can have special features. For example, it can be set in various stages (we will discuss this in more detail later) or has its own lighting integrated.

Range

In larger dogs, the range of the training collar plays a crucial role. After all, a big dog can move away faster, so you have to pay close attention to how long the training collar can be used.

A spiked collar or a collar by Cesar Millan, of course, have no reach in this sense. They work in conjunction with the leash.

If your dog moves beyond the reach of the collar, the training collar may not be properly inserted. Therefore, make sure you are close enough to him during the behavior you want to prevent.

It’s best to stand next to him, so you can use the collar in a timely manner. If you punish him too late, the dog will no longer associate the spray or the vibration with the problem.

Neck Size

Certainly, you have to make sure that the training collar you choose has a good fit. That’s why it is important to know the neck circumference of your dog when purchasing your collar.

You can differentiate between different types of collars. Some are adjustable with a buckle, others work with a flexible, elastic band. If you have a very small dog, you can also benefit from a collar that can be individually cut.

If you do not know which collar is the right one for your dog, try the neck circumference. This criterion eliminates some training collars that may not be available in the right size for your dog.

Weight of the Dog

Similar to the neck size, the weight of the dog plays a certain role. You should not load a very light dog with a very heavy device. Conversely, a large, heavy dog can naturally wear a larger collar with spray function well.

Just imagine, your dog does not want to be restricted by the training collar. He still wants to run, jump and all that with his new collar, preferably near you so he stays in range with the band as well. So to find the right trainer you should also consider the weight of your own dog.

Behavior

Some collars help against a specific problem area. Here one distinguishes between disobedient, running away, pulling on the leash or barking.

Of course, the training collar should be adapted to the problem area your dog brings. A dog with a strong hunting instinct would not be helped by a spiked collar just as much as a dog pulling a leash would not benefit from a spray collar.

If you know the problem area that you want to combat, you can immediately draw conclusions about the appropriate training collar. Pulling on the leash in most cases requires a spiked collar. Barking can be combated by spraying from an anti-bark collar and the hunting instinct or running away can be prevented with vibrations on the training collar.

Best training collars for dogs
It is important that the circumference of the collar fits optimally around the neck of your pet. Well suited are individually adjustable collars or collars made of stretch material. (Photo: Alexas_Fotos / pixabay, com)

Batteries

First, ask yourself how often you want to use the training collar. If the dog sometimes runs too far and occasionally needs to be warned with a spray, then a battery-powered training collar is all it takes.

A battery powered training collar provides up to 30 hours of operational readiness, and the batteries can, of course, be easily replaced.

However, if your dog is constantly digging, chasing other dogs, and you have to be prepared for every walk, then you should rely on a rechargeable, battery-powered training collar.

With a battery-powered training collar, you are better served in the long run, as it can be recharged again and again.

Collars With Multiple Stages

Before you buy, you should ask yourself – how do I want to punish my dog? A training collar offers all the possibilities from the simple step over a spray up to the ten-step amplification of a vibration pulse.

For two-stage training collars, for example, the collar gives a short warning signal before spraying out of the spray container. So the dog is already admonished and knows what can come now to him. If he reacts correctly, then it is no longer necessary to give the spray.

With a training collar of up to ten levels, one can mitigate the punishment accordingly, with ten being the strongest level and one the weakest level of admonition.

So if your dog moves away from you and you want to point out that it’s misconduct, you can admonish him. If he moves further, you push the two, and if he still decides to keep running, follow him and hit the three, and so on.

The ten-step admonition system is suitable for patient dog owners who are sensitive and in some cases just want to reprimand the dog slightly.

The only collars that work without particular steps are the spiked training collars or the Cesar Millan Training Collar. These collars have in principle only one step. The dog regulates the strength by pulling harder or weaker on the leash.


How to Use a Training Collar for Dogs?

The anti-bark collar can be like a normal collar. It usually comes with remote control (except the spiked collar) so you can activate the collar training from a short distance.

Some collars work without a remote control. For example, the spiked collar, that in the best case you put the dog with the spikes outward so that it is not endangered. If you put it in with the spikes inside, the dog will inflict pain when pulling on the leash.

Shock collars used as an invisible fence are also used without remote control. You enter a certain radius in which the dog can stay. When the animal leaves this area, the collar gives out shocks.

Can I rent a training collar?

Training collars should be used for a period between four to six weeks. While some animal coaches may rent out training equipment such as collars, we don’t think it’s a common practice.

If you decide to buy, the rental price is included in most companies and the collar remains altogether the same price. In eight out of ten cases, a problem with the collar can be resolved within a short time. In other cases, the dog may override the punishment, he will not be frightened of the sound or spray.

For dogs older than six, you should plan for about eight weeks of training time to play it safe. Here you can buy instead of rent the education collar directly because there is no difference in price. Of course, if you keep several dogs, you can use your own collar on all dogs.

Prerequisite for success with the collar is that you train regularly. In anti-hunting training, virtually every walk is a training session. Once training is completed, the success of using the Training Collar will last a lifetime.

How Clean Training Collars for Dogs?

The easiest way to clean the training collar with lukewarm water and a little window cleaner. You should not use scratchy sponges or scouring solutions. If heavily soiled, you can also soak most of the training collars in the sink with lukewarm water.

Attention, under no circumstances should you use sharp cleansers on the collars, as these can ruin the training collar. For example, you can penetrate the spray container with spray collars or, in the case of spiked collars, cause corrosion of the chrome-plated areas; which will result in rust.

Can the Dog Wear the Training Collar and a Regular Collar Together?

Since the training collar has no attachment usually, you should always give your four-legged friend his normal collar. The holder of the remote trainer is not intended for attaching a leash. In the case of spray collars, even the spray container could be damaged in the case and the collar loses its meaning.

You should always put his dog collar with the usual dog collar, so he can be safely led on a leash. The exception is the spiked collar, which only engages in conjunction with the leash.


Summary

To recap this article, we have covered our top 5 recommended best training collars for dogs, their specific features and other qualities. We have also covered a wide range of frequently asked questions as well as giving some tips on how to use, and properly maintain your collars.

Keep in mind that not all training collars are suitable for every dog, some things that may affect your choice of the collar is:

  • Local laws and regulations
  • Size of your dog
  • Functionality

It is important that you read up on your local laws and regulations when it comes to training collars for dogs, as some collars may be illegal. Instead of going for the shock collar we recommend you try out the other types of collars first, namely the spray collar and the vibration collar.


If you found this article helpful in deciding which training collar to get for your dog, please don’t forget to share it with friends and family who may also benefit from the information on this list.